Building a Feedback Culture That Actually Works
Quote of the Day: āFeedback isnāt a sandwich. Itās a lifeline..ā
Building a Feedback Culture That Actually Works
Hey good peopleāletās talk about the leadership word we all say we want⦠but secretly dread: feedback.
You know what Iām talking about.
We ask for it, we avoid it, we flinch when we hear it, and sometimes we dish it out like weāre sprinkling glitterāhoping it sticks somewhere helpful.
Hereās the real talk: feedback isnāt a sandwich. Itās a lifeline. And if weāre serious about leading with accountability (yep, the same accountability we talked about in the last post), weāve got to get serious about how we give it, ask for it, and receive it.
Because when feedback is missing, guess what takes its place?
š Confusion.
š Resentment.
š Mistrust.
Teams start guessing. Leaders assume everythingās fine. And before you know it, small issues turn into big blow-ups.
Why Feedback Feels So Hard
First, letās name the elephant in the room: feedback is uncomfortable.
We donāt want to hurt feelings. We donāt want to rock the boat. And weāve bought into the myth that if weāre ānice enough,ā people will just get better on their own.
Spoiler alert: they wonāt.
And hereās the kickerāby avoiding hard conversations, youāre not protecting people. Youāre confusing them. Youāre letting blind spots grow. Youāre creating a culture where no one really knows how theyāre doing.
Shift the GoalāItās Not About Being Comfortable
The goal of feedback is not to make you feel good. Itās not even about making the other person feel good.
Itās about helping them grow.
Hereās how I like to frame it: feedback = clarity + care.
Clarity with no care? Thatās harsh.
Care with no clarity? Thatās fluffy and unhelpful.
Your team deserves both. They deserve a leader who can say:
āI see this in you. Youāre capable of more. And hereās how weāll get there together.ā
Thatās not easy. But thatās leadership.
How to Build a Feedback Culture
If you want feedback to feel normal (instead of a once-a-year HR event), it starts with you.
Invite it first.
Ask your team, āWhatās one thing I could do better as your leader?ā And when they answer, donāt defend yourself. Just receive it and thank them.
2. Make it frequent.
Feedback shouldnāt be a shock. If your people only hear how theyāre doing once a year, youāre doing it wrong.
3. Pair recognition with coaching.
Catch them doing something great. Celebrate it. Then coach them where they need it. This balance builds trust.
4. Focus on the behavior, not the person.
āI noticed you missed two deadlines this month,ā is a lot more productive than, āYouāre lazy.ā
5. Close the loop.
Circle back after you give feedback. āHey, howās it going since we talked?ā shows that youāre invested in their growthānot just ticking a box.
Feedback Up and Sideways (Yep, Itās a Thing)
Feedback isnāt just for your teamāit flows upward and sideways too.
Giving feedback to peers or your boss can feel tricky, but the same rules apply: clarity + care. Frame it as partnership and shared success:
āI noticed X, and I want to support you in Y. How can I help?ā
When your team sees you give and receive feedback in all directions, it sets the tone: this is just how we work here.
Feedback is the Rhythm
Feedback isnāt a one-time event. Itās the rhythm that keeps teams healthy.
When you create a culture where feedback flows freely, youāll notice:
Problems get solved faster.
Trust deepens.
People stop guessing and start growing.
Because feedback isnāt about perfectionāitās about giving your team the clarity and confidence they need to do their best work.
Grab a notebook (or a teammate) and work through these three:
Who on your team is waiting for feedback youāve been avoiding giving? Write down exactly what needs to be saidāand when youāll say it.
Who havenāt you asked for feedback from lately? Send them a quick message today: āWhatās one thing I could do better as your leader?ā
Whatās going really well in your leadership right now? Write it down. Celebrate it. And ask yourself how you can do more of it.
Keep workingā¦itās always worth it. And hard doesnāt last forever and is where the magic happens.